Comparing Top Eyeshadow Palettes and an Eyeliner for 2023


Hey there! If you’ve been on the lookout for some fantastic new eyeshadow palettes or an eye-catching eyeliner to spice up your makeup routine, you’re in the right place. Today, we’re going to chat about a couple of gorgeous eyeshadow palettes from LAURA GELLER NEW YORK and L.A. COLORS, as well as a vibrant eyeliner from NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP. Whether you’re going for a natural look, a touch of drama, or anything in between, we’ve got some great options to consider.

Eyeshadows and eyeliners have been staples in the beauty world for years, beloved for their ability to instantly transform your look with just a few swipes. A good eyeshadow palette offers versatility—think all the shades you need to go from daytime glam to a sultry evening vibe. Meanwhile, a quality eyeliner can make your eyes pop, enhancing their natural beauty or adding a striking touch of color. Owning these products means never being more than a few minutes away from a polished, put-together look, regardless of your skill level or occasion.

In the rest of this article, you’ll get a closer look at each of these products. We’ll cover the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette, the Casual Collection Berry & Blossom Palette, the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette in Haute, and the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil in Emerald Empire. So, if you’re ready to elevate your makeup game, keep reading!

Laura Geller Earthy Essentials Eyeshadow Palette with 14 Natural Shades

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette | 14 Pigmented Eyeshadows Blendable Natural Look

When it comes to eyeshadows, the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette is a versatile option designed for those who love to play with a mix of neutral, brown, and earthy tones. This palette offers 14 highly pigmented eyeshadows that allow you to create both simple and stunning looks, making it perfect for daily wear as well as more dramatic, evening styles. Whether you’re aiming for a subtle daytime look or an intense smoky eye, this palette has got you covered.

You can never go wrong with a neutral palette, especially when it’s as versatile and high-quality as this one. The first thing that stands out with this palette is its range of matte and shimmer finishes, which offers the opportunity to experiment with different textures and looks. The eyeshadows are creamy and crease-proof, ensuring that your eye makeup looks freshly applied all day long. Plus, it’s so easy to blend! Minimal fallout means you won’t have to worry about touching up too often, making this palette ideal for busy mornings or nights out.

This palette excels in providing everything you need for a natural look. Whether you need a light base shade, a good mid-tone for the crease, or a deep shade to sculpt and define, this palette has you covered. Here’s what you’ll find inside:

These shades range from neutral eyeshadows perfect for a subtle look to rich earthy tones that define and enhance your eyes. With a good mix of both mattes and shimmers, you can create any look you desire, be it simple or more dramatic.

Another noteworthy feature is the creaminess of these eyeshadows. They are baked from cream pigments over a 24-hour period, resulting in a smooth and blendable texture that adheres to your skin without creasing.

The palette is designed to be user-friendly, making it comfortable for both beginners and makeup pros. To get started:

  1. Light Base Shade – Sweep a light shade over the entire eyelid.
  2. Mid-Tone for Crease – Apply a mid-tone shade into the crease to define your look.
  3. Sculpt with Deeper Shades – Use a deeper shade on the outer corner for added depth.
  4. Shimmer for Drama – Apply a shimmer shade to the inner corners or the center of the eyelids for a more dramatic finish.

When looking at the quality, the LAURA GELLER EARTHY ESSENTIALS BAKED EYESHADOW PALETTE stands out for its longevity and pigmentation. Baked eyeshadows traditionally offer more intense color payoff, and with this palette, each shade delivers true-to-pan color. The smooth and blendable texture means you can easily mix and match without worrying about harsh lines.

  • Highly Pigmented Eyeshadows: Each of the 14 shades offers strong color payoff.

  • Versatile Range of Shades: Includes both matte and shimmer options in neutral, brown, and earthy tones.

  • Creamy & Crease-Proof: Longer-lasting wear due to its creamy consistency that resists creasing.

  • Easy to Blend: The blendable texture makes it simple to create a flawless look.

  • Minimal Fallout: Ensures cleaner application and reduces the need for touch-ups.

  • Limited to Neutral/Earthy Tones: While ideal for everyday and natural looks, those seeking vibrant colors may find the palette lacking.

  • Price Point: Higher price compared to some drugstore brand palettes, but the quality typically justifies the investment.

The LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette is an excellent choice for makeup enthusiasts looking for a versatile, high-quality eyeshadow palette that provides long-lasting wear and a range of natural and earthy tones. From offering a blendable and crease-proof formula to its rich pigmentation, this palette checks all the boxes for creating beautiful eye makeup looks effortlessly.

Shop Now

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Berry & Blossom Eyeshadow Palette – 14 Shades

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry  Blossom 14 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows | 14 Pigmented Eyeshadows Blendable Natural Look

The LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom 14 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows is designed to be your go-to palette for creating an array of stunning eyeshadow looks. Whether you’re aiming for a subtle, natural daytime look or a dramatic, bold evening statement, this palette’s versatility makes it an excellent addition to your makeup collection. Its blendable formulas ensure that even beginners can achieve professional-looking results with just a few brush strokes.

One of the reasons why the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom Eyeshadow Palette has captured our attention is due to its thoughtfully curated shades. The palette includes both matte and shimmer eyeshadows, making it versatile for any makeup enthusiast. We also appreciate the berry and floral-inspired hues, which are flattering on all eye colors and skin tones. The highly pigmented shadows promise a rich color payoff that lasts, ensuring your makeup looks stunning all day (or night) long.

This palette is packed with 14 multi-finish eyeshadows that give you endless ways to enhance your eyes. Here’s a breakdown of what it offers:

  • Fourteen Shades: The selection includes a mix of matte and shimmer shades, inspired by dreamy berry tones and floral hues. This provides versatility for creating a wide range of looks, from natural to dramatic.

  • Highly Pigmented Shadows: The high pigmentation means that a little product goes a long way, delivering intense color that stays put without fading or creasing.

  • Blendable and Silky Texture: The eyeshadows have a silky texture that makes blending effortless, allowing you to create seamless transitions between colors.

  • Long-Lasting Formulation: The colors are designed to be crease-proof and comfortable to wear, so you don’t have to worry about touch-ups throughout the day.

  • User-Friendly Application: Whether you prefer sweeping a single shade over the eyelid for a quick, natural look or layering multiple shades to add depth and dimension, this palette accommodates various application techniques.

When it comes to overall quality, the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Eyeshadow Palette does not disappoint. The pigmentation is rich and vibrant, offering considerable color payoff with minimal effort. The shadows are exceptionally blendable, thanks to their silky texture, which makes them easy to work with, even for beginners. Additionally, the long-lasting formula ensures the colors remain crease-proof and comfortable from morning until night. The thoughtfully selected shades complement a wide array of skin tones and eye colors, making this palette a versatile tool in anyone’s makeup arsenal.

  • Versatile Shade Range: With 14 different shades encompassing both mattes and shimmers, you have the flexibility to create countless looks suitable for any occasion.

  • High Pigmentation: The eyeshadows in this palette provide a rich color payoff, reducing the need for multiple layers and ensuring a vibrant finish.

  • Blendable Texture: The silky, blendable texture makes application a breeze, allowing for smooth transitions and polished looks.

  • Long-Lasting: Designed to be crease-proof and comfortable for long wear, you can trust that your eye makeup will stay intact throughout the day.

  • Universal Appeal: The berry and floral-inspired hues are flattering on all skin tones and eye colors, making it a versatile choice for anyone.

  • Needs Primer for Maximum Durability: Though the shadows are long-lasting, using an eyeshadow primer can help intensify the color and ensure the look stays vibrant even longer.

  • Fallout Potential: Some users have reported minor fallout during application, which is common with highly pigmented shadows. This can be managed with a good eyeshadow primer or by doing your eye makeup before your base foundation.

The LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom 14 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows palette stands out for its beautiful selection of colors, blendable textures, and high-quality formulation. Whether you are a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, this palette offers endless possibilities to enhance your eye looks.

Amazon

L.A. COLORS 16-Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute, 1.02 oz

L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute, 1.02 Ounce

The L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute, 1.02 Ounce is designed to give your eyes a stunning, vibrant look. Whether you’re opting for a dramatic evening appearance or a more subtle, everyday glow, this palette has got you covered. It’s perfect for anyone who wants to experiment with different looks without breaking the bank.

One of the biggest reasons we love this palette is its versatility. From matte to shimmer finishes, the array of colors ensures that you can effortlessly transition from day to night. The added convenience of a dual-ended applicator simplifies the process, especially if you’re on the go. The expertly curated colors cater to a range of skin tones and preferences, making it a must-have for any eyeshadow enthusiast.

The main goal of the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette is to deliver high-impact, fashionable eye looks for an ultra-affordable price. Here are some of the standout features:

With 16 different shades, this palette offers a vibrant color combination that suits various occasions and moods. You can create endless looks, from a subtle nude to a bold, dramatic eye.

This palette cleverly balances between matte and shimmer finishes, offering a mix that is perfect for crafting a multitude of eye-catching looks. The matte shades work wonderfully for base colors and blending, while the shimmer shades add that extra pop of glamour.

The inclusion of a dual-ended applicator ensures you have a ready-to-use tool for both applying and blending. This is especially useful if you’re traveling or need to do quick touch-ups throughout the day.

The compact size of this single 1.02-ounce palette makes it easy to slip into your purse or travel bag, yet it doesn’t skimp on variety, offering 16 potent shades.

Given its budget-friendly price point, the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette offers surprisingly good quality. The pigmentation is satisfactory across the board, with some shades performing exceptionally well, particularly the shimmers. While the staying power is decent, using a good primer can enhance longevity and vibrancy. Each shade is blendable and buildable, allowing you to create a seamless look whether you’re a beginner or a pro.

  • Affordability: The palette offers an impressive range of shades for a very reasonable price.

  • Versatility: With both matte and shimmer options, you can create looks for any occasion.

  • Compact and Portable: Its small size makes it perfect for on-the-go use.

  • Dual-Ended Applicator: Simplifies the application process.

  • Pigmentation Variance: While most shades deliver good pigment, some may require layering to achieve the desired intensity.

  • Longevity: To ensure the eyeshadow lasts all day, you might need to use a primer.

If you are looking for a versatile eyeshadow palette that won’t make a dent in your wallet, the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute, 1.02 Ounce is well worth considering. It offers a fantastic blend of variety and quality, making it a valuable addition to your makeup collection.

Add To Cart

NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil, Emerald Green Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil, Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner - Emerald Empire, Emerald Green Eyeliner

The NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Pencil in Emerald Empire is designed to provide a striking and precise eyeliner look with ease. Whether you’re aiming for a subtle, everyday pop of color or a bold, dramatic statement, this eyeliner is crafted to meet your needs. Its versatile formula is perfect for creating rich, vivid lines that make your eyes stand out.

We adore this eyeliner for its vibrant color payoff and ease of application. The shade Emerald Empire, a stunning emerald green, adds a unique twist to your traditional eyeliner collection. Unlike many other eyeliners, the NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Pencil boasts a creamy, retractable formula that doesn’t require sharpening, making it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups.

Moreover, it comes from a brand known for its commitment to cruelty-free cosmetics. NYX is certified by PETA, meaning no animal testing is involved at any stage of the product’s creation. This aligns perfectly with a growing preference for ethical beauty products in the market today.

The main purpose of the NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Pencil in Emerald Empire is to offer a one-swipe eyeliner application with intense color that lasts all day. Perfect for defining your eyes, this product aims to enhance your makeup routine with minimal effort and maximum impact.

  1. Vivid Rich Shades: Available in 12 shades, this eyeliner offers a range of colors from matte to shimmer and metallic finishes.
  2. Creamy Gem-Tone Pigments: Each pencil is loaded with creamy pigments that deliver rich, jewel-toned color in just one swipe.
  3. Mechanical and Retractable: Say goodbye to sharpeners! This retractable pencil makes application easier and more efficient.
  4. Cruelty-Free: Certified by PETA as a cruelty-free product, ensuring no animals were harmed in its production.
  5. Versatile Use: Mix and match different shades for a creative, multi-colored look or keep it simple with a monochrome style.
  6. Long-Lasting: Formulated to stay put, it offers extensive wear without smudging or fading.

When it comes to quality, the NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Pencil in Emerald Empire excels across the board. The product’s creamy formula ensures a smooth application devoid of tugging or pulling at the delicate skin around your eyes. Additionally, the emerald green shade is both vibrant and deep, providing a long-lasting color that doesn’t easily smudge or fade.

The build quality of the mechanical pencil is robust yet practical. The retractable feature is particularly noteworthy, offering convenience and conserving the product. With consistent performance across different types of weather and conditions, this eyeliner is a reliable addition to any beauty regimen.

  • Bold Color: The emerald green color is vivid and eye-catching, perfect for those who want to make a statement.

  • Ease of Use: The retractable, mechanical design eliminates the need for sharpening and ensures easy application.

  • Creamy Texture: Provides a smooth glide with no tugging or skipping, making it ideal for all skill levels.

  • Versatility: Suitable for various looks, whether you’re going for subtle or dramatic.

  • Cruelty-Free: Certified by PETA, ensuring ethical production practices.

  • Long-Wearing: Stays put throughout the day without significant smudging or fading.

  • Limited Shades: Although the 12 available shades are vivid and beautiful, the range might feel limited to those seeking more natural or understated colors.

  • Size of the Product: Some users might find the pencil size smaller compared to traditional eyeliners, leading to more frequent repurchasing.

The NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Pencil, Emerald Empire stands out as a go-to product for adding a splash of bold color to your eye makeup routine. Its easy-to-use design, coupled with ethical production standards, make it a must-have in your vanity kit.

Add To Cart

Comparison of Eyeshadow Palettes and Eyeliner

When it comes to choosing the perfect eye makeup products, you want to ensure you find something that aligns with your style and needs. I’ve reviewed four popular choices in the market: The LAURA GELLER NEW YORK palettes, the L.A. COLORS palette, and the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil. Let’s break down their specifications and see how they stack up against each other.

Product Specifications

Feature LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom Eyeshadow Palette L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil, Emerald Empire
Number of Eyeshadows 14 14 16 N/A
Type of Shades Neutral, Brown, Earth Tones (Matte & Shimmer) Berry & Floral-Inspired Hues (Matte & Shimmer) Matte & Shimmer Gem-Tone Pigments (Matte, Shimmer & Metallic)
Texture Creamy, Crease-proof Silky, Crease-proof Varied Creamy
Longevity Long-lasting, minimal fallout Long-lasting Standard Long-lasting
Cruelty-free Not specified Not specified Not specified Yes
Extra Features Baked from cream pigments, minimal fallout Highly pigmented, flattering on all skin tones Dual-ended applicator Retractable, easy application
Application Tips Sweep light shade as base, mid-tone to crease, deeper shade for depth Single shade for natural look or multiple for depth Use matte for base, shimmer for highlight 1-swipe application, mix & match for varied looks
Weight Not specified Not specified 1.02 oz N/A

Key Highlights

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette

  • Versatile Shades: This palette offers 14 neutral, brown, and earthy tones perfect for creating either simple or dramatic looks.
  • Texture: The baked eyeshadows are creamy and crease-proof, offering a smooth blendable texture with minimal fallout.
  • Application: Perfect for defining your eyes with matte or shimmer finishes.

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom Eyeshadow Palette

  • Unique Tones: Offers a blend of berry tones and floral-inspired hues suitable for any season, flattering on all skin tones.
  • Built for Versatility: With both matte and shimmer shades, this palette allows endless creativity.
  • Pigmentation: Highly pigmented shadows with a silky texture that blends effortlessly.

L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute

  • Variety: Includes 16 vibrant colors with both matte and shimmer finishes.
  • Ease of Use: Comes with a dual-ended applicator for quick touch-ups.
  • Affordability: Typically more budget-friendly without compromising on color variety.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil, Emerald Empire

  • Bold Shades: Boasts a range of vivid shades in matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes.
  • Convenience: Retractable pencil design eliminates the need for sharpening.
  • Ethical Choice: Cruelty-free and certified by PETA, making it a conscious choice for makeup enthusiasts.

Whether you’re leaning towards a full eyeshadow palette or a rich eyeliner, each of these products offers unique benefits. For natural and earthy tones, LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Palette might be your best bet. If you’re into vibrant berry shades, the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Casual Collection Palette is ideal. For a more extensive color collection at a lower price, the L.A. COLORS Palette stands out. And for those who love a striking eyeliner look, the NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil provides rich, one-swipe pigmentation. Happy experimenting!

Conclusion and Recommendations

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette

If you’re someone who loves natural and earthy tones, LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Delectables Earthy Essentials Baked Eyeshadow Palette is an excellent choice. With 14 pigmented shades, this palette promises a blendable and smooth application. It’s perfect for creating a subtle, natural look that can easily transition from day to night. However, some users have noted that a few shades might require layering for more intense pigmentation. So, if you prefer highly pigmented eyeshadows right out of the gate, this might need a bit more effort on your part.

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom 14 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows

For those who enjoy a mix of finishes and shades, the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Berry & Blossom delivers with its 14 multi-finish eyeshadows. These shades are beautifully pigmented and offer a blendable texture. Perfect for creating both casual and glamorous looks, it adds versatility to your makeup routine. One minor drawback is that the shimmer shades can sometimes produce fallout, so just be sure to do your eye makeup before your foundation.

L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute

If you’re budget-conscious but still want a wide range of colors, the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Haute is a fantastic choice. With 16 varied hues, you have lots of creative freedom. The pigmentation is impressive for its price point, and the colors are highly blendable. However, some users have experienced slight chalkiness in a few shades, so keep that in mind if you’re expecting a high-end feel.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil, Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner – Emerald Empire

Your eyeliner game can reach new heights with the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil in Emerald Empire. This creamy, retractable eyeliner provides a vivid emerald green hue that can elevate any eye look. It’s easy to apply and doesn’t tug on your delicate eye area. However, it may smudge a bit in very humid conditions, so consider setting it with a matching eyeshadow for extra longevity.

Final Recommendation

For an overall diversified palette collection, LAURA GELLER offers superior blendability and pigmentation, tailor-made for both natural and chic looks. If you’re more focused on cost-effectiveness or experimenting with different colors, the L.A. COLORS palette is a solid choice. Finally, if eyeliner is your must-have product, the NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil in Emerald Empire is your go-to for a pop of color.

Audience-Specific Recommendation

If you’re a makeup enthusiast who loves to play around with different looks and values a mix of quality and affordability, integrating all four products into your makeup arsenal will certainly elevate your beauty routine. Each has its unique strength, so based on the occasion and your preferences, you’ll always have the right tool in hand.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Luxurybeautyreviews.onlineAuthor posts

Avatar for luxurybeautyreviews.online

Hi there! I'm luxurybeautyreviews.online, the voice behind Thoughtful Review: Luxury Items Deserving the Higher Price Tag. As the founder and editor of this website, I welcome you to dive into a world of opulence and explore meticulously curated luxury beauty reviews. Beyond ordinary, my goal is to decode elegance one product at a time. From exquisite skincare to haute fragrances, I provide insights from the finest in the industry to elevate your beauty regimen. With a passion for all things luxurious, I invite you to join me on this journey and unlock the secrets of the beauty world. Welcome to Luxury Beauty Reviews!